I recently read an interesting comment by the Danish sociologist Lars Jørgensen in the Danish newspaper Arbejderen (the worker). It was about media’s responsibility for the war in Syria, and I agree that they have caused many of the problems. It has to do with Hitler’s trick, as Jørgensen called it. Hitler knew, according to the comment in Arbejderen, that ordinary people couldn’t make themselves believe that their own leaders would shamelessly lie to them to justify war. That makes people inclined to contribute to their own oppression.
The argument is convincing at the same time as it’s hard to understand why people would do this. There were undoubtedly people in the 1930’s and 40’s that didn’t want to see the truth, and there are people today that don’t want to see their political heroes as liars. At the same time we have a resonsibility to reflect on what governmets and journalists tell us. We can accept everything we read and hear as truth, but having that level of naivity is a choice we make. I have read many accounts of Germans that actively opposed Hitler, during the war and they were not all Jews. The situation might be different today because we are not talking about our closest neighbours and fellow citizens, but a population in a country most people had barely heard about before the war started.
I believe people know when their political leaders are lying. They knew Hitler was wrong from the start and they knew the wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Syria were not about helping the people or making our own countries safer. Incidentally, two British Parlamentary reports into the wars in Iraq and Libya concluded that they were based on lies. Politicians and media failed us, but those few journalists, activsts and scholars that have tried to follow the evidence of for example gas attacks in Syria, point towards the rebels, the so-called moderate islamists. It’s not that it’s not being reported at all, but articles like UN has testimony that Syrian rebels used sarin gas:investigator from Reuters are usually ignored. We don’t want to know. I believe the Hitler trick still very much sums up how the democracy we want to share with the rest of the world works.
I believe you have a pretty good idea that news and statements from the government are narrations, but we like it when it makes us look strong and when it doesn’t have any consequences for us. We are being told a version of the truth, and in that sense I don’t think there is a country without a conspiracy. There are no known cases of a conspiracy in Norway. Nothing has ever been exposed, although there are some suspicious cases, but when I read the news and compare it to independent news from Syria, I know there is a Hitler trick in operation. Anything else would be a child’s naive fantasy.